Guide

Two Great Pet Photos, One Case: A Simple Crop Test

October 27, 2026 3 min read By GoCraftly
Editorial illustration comparing two crops of a golden retriever photograph.

One photo has your dog's best head tilt. Another shows the whole dog, but the expression is quieter. Which belongs on a case? Rather than picking the winner in your camera roll, compare how each picture works in the space the case gives you.

This is a selection exercise for photos you already have. If you are taking new pictures, start with our pet photography guide.

Name the detail you want to keep

Before adjusting anything, decide what makes each photo special. It might be a crooked ear, a white patch on the chest, a sleepy face, or a favorite toy. Write down that one detail for each candidate. This keeps you from improving the layout so much that you crop away the reason you chose the picture.

Keep the original files unchanged. Work from copies if you want to prepare alternate crops, and name them clearly so you do not upload the wrong version later.

Compare both on the same phone selection

Choose the intended phone model and case style in Design Your Own. Assess each image against the same selection. Comparing one photo on one model and the other on a different model adds an unnecessary variable.

For each candidate, look at three areas: the face, the camera opening, and the outside edges. Can you keep the eyes and your chosen detail comfortably visible? Does the photo still feel balanced after you move it? If getting the face into position removes both ears or the favorite toy, try the other image before forcing the crop.

Give each photo a short scorecard

  • Recognition: Can you see your pet's expression without leaning in?
  • Breathing room: Is there space around the features you want to keep?
  • Background: Does anything distracting compete with the face?
  • Meaning: Is the detail you loved still present?

You do not need a numeric score. A simple “works,” “needs adjustment,” or “choose another” beside each point is enough. A candid photo can win over a formal portrait if its expression survives the crop more naturally.

Stop if both options feel forced

Neither favorite has to become the case. Try a third picture with more room around the pet, or keep the busiest image for a photo album. Avoid making the subject tiny just to preserve every background detail.

Our general photo checklist can help with source-file quality. Once you settle on a candidate, review the full layout again before saving. The goal is a recognizable little portrait you enjoy seeing, with the expression that made you choose it in the first place.

Share your thoughts

Comments are reviewed before they appear publicly.